I like this thead and I can't decide on my vote yet. FTR, I like Lucas, but more as a Jets fan than as a QB. My decision is between Chad and Vinny. Vinny made games exciting. I remember always feeling like we were in his games. But Chad I was biased in favor of from the day we drafted him. I always thought we were destined to win with him (and then he'd get hurt). So I can't decide between those two. And Favre WOULD HAVE been my favorite, but I'll never forget the Miami game and the pre-game speech, and this soiled my memory of him forever.
That was one of the best QB season's of the last 20 years. Certainly, the best in our franchise's history ever. He was so fucking efficient that season. hahah....very out of character in line with the rest of his career.
Definitely Chad, followed by Vinny. No matter what, you knew those two would give it their all and do whatever it took to try to win the game. Chad gets the nod because he played smart football, and always gave us a chance. I will always wonder what would have been if Chad was not snake-bitten and managed to stay healthy...
In defense of Sanchez Vinny and Chad were here a lot longer then he has been so far. In 3 years we could all be looking at this completely different.
This is like asking which one of my Kids I'd least like to beat because they are a complete dissapointment. For now is Sanchez because I'm banking on a big future still. Outside of that I'd go with Vinny.
Shame on whoever didn't vote for Kellen Clemens. His TD run VS the Bills week 17 of last year was awesome... lest we forget.
I move to end all "Eric Smith is black" jokes until we have a safety to knock him down the depth chart.
