Rosen vs Mayfield at the 3 pick - what the film shows

I phrased that wrong in Darnold I’m seeing a Montana

Poise of Montana
Favre type scramble ability similar arm but not as big.
Reminds me of Russ Wilson a bit the way he can create. Granted not as quick.

 

This is the Thread people should be talking in.

I think it is likely that Josh Allen goes #1 to Cleveland, then Sam Darnold goes #2 to the Giants. Leaving the Jets to choose between Rosen and Mayfield.

Rosen rightfully has a 79% to 21% lead on Mayfield, but I know many TGG posters who would choose Mayfield. It will be interesting to see what the Jets do if the Draft falls like this.

 

At this point, I think I'd be stunned if Darnold doesn't go to the Browns at 1. If he doesn't, it guarantees the Jets one of Rosen/Darnold which would be wonderful. In your situation, it's gotta be Rosen to the Jets.

 

Rosen will be gone before the 3rd pick. I think it will be Mayfield or Allen. I really lean in the Mayfield corner.

 

I have difficulty believing the Giants will take a QB. The last time they had a pick in the top 3 they got Lawrence Taylor. Now they are in a position to get another one (Chubb).



It says the survey is informal, but can the Giants really pass on a generational talent to gamble on a QB? I really don't think so. Browns will get Darnold, Jets will choose between Rosen/Mayfield.

 

Possible, but they need a successor to Eli and will likely not pick in the top 5 again for a while. It makes a lot of sense to for the G Men to take a QB, so I won't rule it out.

 

Is it just me, or does watching highlights of Rosen SCREAM Chad Pennington at Marshall? Every throw is short and deep passes are slightly (very slightly, but it's there) underthrown. Seems to be very accurate, but I'm worried he would be one shoulder injury away from Chad part two.

Mayfield seems like a project. Not a fan. Darnold will be gone and Allen scares the hell out of me.

 

Isn't that every QB? Definitely don't want to tear your rotator cuff. And Chad is probably the best Jets QB since Namath, so not sure that would scare me off of Rosen if he seems similar to you.

 

the Baker to the jets momentum has picked up tremendously since he visited on Monday.


Rosen's stock seems to be dropping fast among the media people (take that for what it's worth).. Allen and Darnold sound like the 1 & 2 and everyone is saying jets are LOVING Baker.

it's just media folk though so no telling what's really the truth, but by following all them it sounds like Rosen could fall.

 

It scares me because Chad's game was so limited. Rosen looks like a dump-off/short pass guy, and receivers are coming back to the ball a lot of his deeper throws.

 

Rosen has a very live arm, much better than Chad coming out.

 

I've come a long way with Mayfield to the point where I now see him a desirable option for the Jets, but if he and Rosen are there, short of his injury concerns being more significant than I realize, I couldn't understand passing on Rosen for Mayfield (from my non-expert perspective FWIW)

 

Are you aware of Rosen's injury concerns? Or his father? Or his intellectual challenges?

The guy has so many red flags that he should be a golf course.

 

That's hilarious

 

I've wanted Rosen all along. Baker to me is Sanchez level talent wise with MUCH better attitude, leadership, intangibles.

 

Execution. Sanchez was such an unfinished product at the college level that Pete Carroll was right, he never should have come out.

Baker is 1000 times a more polished player on the field. His personality is the real concern with stature second. Somebody needs to follow him around with private investigators. Oh wait.

 

I think Baker also has a better arm

 

In such a QB driven league I have a hard time believing the VaGiants would be so stupid to pass up on a qb from this incredible class. Especially with a weak 2019 class looming.