To be clear I was not voting to bring Turner back. I was merely noting we have not seen any of these young guys you refer to actually play. They might all suck.
The difference is if you believe in redemption or not. I do. I am no fan of what Mike Vick did by any means. I thought it was horrific. But that's not the whole story. I think it is reasonably clear Vick turned a corner and is not only conscious of the need to be a different person, but as far as I can tell is a better person. Richie has yet to demonstrate any of that.