I'm just saying the way you defended him was overzealous. While I don't see Rhodes losing his starting job, I think Magini's the kind of guy that will make sure everyone has to compete to keep their job. So Maddox should get a fair shot at going for it.
Because it never looked like Andre could be our starting safety. He's slow as shit and cant cover. He's a tackling machine, yeah, but he was never in a position to beat Celestin/Rhodes out. It was all about Rhodes and Celestin. Maddox looked like he could be a great special teamer but thats all...
Dude obviously he cant beat out Rhodes while injured, its when hes healthy, do I think he will beat out Rhodes? no. However he will have a shot and its not unreasonable to think. I dont know why you get offended when someone criticizes him. Just tell us how you are related to him? Its obvious that you have some sort of relation.
