D'Brick: 84 Mangold: 79 Clemens: 77 Other picks Mario Williams: 84 Reggie Bush: 85 Vince Young: 83 Matt Leinart: 81 Vernon Davis: 83 Jay Cutler: 80
I think you got D'Brick and Mangold correct but I think Clemens will be between 74 low and 79 high . But I think 78 should be right on the button .
The one thing I love about D'Brick is that his arms are huge! If he just extends those nobody is getting around!
I think you guys are a little too high on Mangold and Clemens. Usually the #29pick is not rated that high (an 80 or 81), even though he is one of the better centers. And I doubt Clemens will be anywhere near a 79. I think Manning was only an 81 when he came in, and Roethlisberger was a 79 as the #3 quarterback and the #11 pick. Alex Smith wasnt rated very high either (an 80 or something?). A late second round pick and the third string starter behind Penny and Ramsey I doubt will be that high. I predict... Ferguson: 83 Mangold: 78 Clemens: 73
Ferguson: 83 Mangold: 80 (He is the best player at his position from the draft so he will get some love) Clemens: 75 Anthony Schegel: 71 Eric Smith: 70 Brad Smith: 70 Leon Washington: 69
Ferguson 83 Mangold 79 Clemens 75 w/ 93 pass power 84 accuracy maybe 62 speed Schlegel 71 Smith 70 Washington 70 w/ 91 speed Smith 70 w/ 90 speed
Tell me 'bout it! Even when we have a good team we get rated like we sucked the Year before then When we Suck, they rate us cause we're gonna suck We never get a fair shake..
Vilma SHOULD be AT LEAST a 92, hes definitely proven himself to be a top 5 MLB in the league. Id go with a 94 to be fair, but who knows what theyll rate him. Its a tough one to guess. Other than him I dont know well have any players above a 90. Maybe Ellis, but thats a tough one to gauge as well. Id say 88/89 for him, to be safe. Nuge should be around an 87 IMO, as should Barton
Your ratings should be true but I feel the people at EA may not be objective enough and will give Nugent a 84 and Barton an 85 , n I guess Vilma will be our lone player 90+
Wasnt Nuge an 84 coming out? If theres any player thatll be rated fair its him, IMO. Kaeding was about an 86, so I think Nuge will be a tad better. Barton was doin alright before he got hurt. He started the season at 88 I believe and they usually don take muchh if anything off when they players get put on IR. 87 sounds right to me...Ellis is the tricky one, as is Coles and Penny
