Who wouldn't want Quinn over Cutler. At least Quinn knows how to win a game. He's gone toe to toe with the best teams in the league and pulled some great wins but also had some tough losses. Cutler is just a practice player who will always look great when throwing inside an empty gym, but put him on the field with 21 other players and he is just average.
Because Dre Bly > David Barrett And Shaun Rogers > Dewayne Robertson And the benefit of moving up 5 picks does not seem to outweigh that for them. Not to mention cap penalties.
I dont want us to lose. In fact either way wed be better off if Chad came back at full power and won us games. Id rather that happen than us having to once again address the position. But if he cant than most likely wed be in prime position to snag Quinn. Its not like Cutler would start this year anyway, so either way, without Chad, I dont see us doing well period
I think I'd go with the good but not great team with tons of depth. Just look up to FoxBoro for that. Do they have any great players or a bunch of good players with incredible depth that have bought into a system that we are going to try to impliment here. I'll take no superstars with great depth over a team with 1 or 2 superstars that take up 1/4 of the salary cap which leaves no room for solid backups.... ie the 2005 New York Jets