Leinart or Young? - hypothetical?

QB next year, O-line defence this year. I would wait for the chad situation to unfold.

 

I say that if you're going for Leinart, then you don't pick up Ramsey.

 

If ramsey's part of the trade he could make a good satopgap for leinart when he's on the bench

 

We would be making the a BIG mistake if we don't take Young. The man has the full package.

 

experience in a pro system? reading defenses? mismatches? blocking adjustments? there's more to being a qb than throwing and he's not event great at that

 

http://www.qisports.com/mattleinart2006.html

After watching this, if you don't have goosebumps then check for a pulse :beer:

I can already hear the Jets radio announcer screaming..."Touchdown! What a throw by Matt Leinart!"

 

Trading up to get Lineart is dumb..... stay put see whats there at 4 then draft.... simple as that.

 

None of the above.

Trade for Ramsey and draft DeAngelo.

 

you just said everything every QB needs to go threw once he come to the NFL.

 

It's only dumb if you don't want him.

 

Part of the trade for the #2 pick?

 

You will never learn will you? We arent drafting Deangelo!

 

QB is not a need, go with BPA...

but if we DID take a QB, Young at 4 would be my for sure choice

 

ahh i think lienhart , no i definately would want lienhart. I dont belive in this scrambling qb era.

 

Yes, but atleast most of them have done those things before, be it at a collegiate level. They've done all of that. Leinart would have to get adjusted to new players, a faster game, and nfl defenses. Vince young is a project that would likely require a tutor like mcnair and a great offensive staff to get the most out of him.