Round 1 - Brooks Reed, OLB - Arizona Round 3 - Quinton Carter, Safety - Oklahoma Round 4 - Colin McCarthy, MLB - Miami Round 5 - Sione Fua, NT - Stanford
I would like a little bit more explanation in some of these picks but not bad as far as players go, although Id MUCH rather go CB,DE, OLine, WR, or even RB before a MLB was picked.
I would have mixed feelings about that draft. I'm cooling a little on Reed and Fua, and don't like Carter at all. I also think Rd 3 is way too high for him. McCarthy might be ok. I don't know too much about him, but the depth at ILB is very questionable. I like addressing all the positions you did.
Carter is a good safety and most drafts have him going in the 3rd, I wanted to address safety and it was between him and Robert Sands from West Virginia. McCarthy is a good MLB, I like his style and i think he could be a Rex type of guy and we need more depth at ILB like you said.
True. I kind of passed on Wide out with the hope that we resign Edwards and Holmes. I thought about Corner but i thought Safety was more of a need as of now.
The PFW Value Chart has him as a top of the 4th round pick. I've also seen him listed somewhere as a 5th rounder. Even if he is a 3rd rounder, I don't like him that much. I'd rather have Jaiquawn Jarrett and maybe Marcus Gilchrist over Carter at S, but that's just me. Of course, you could be right and Carter be the better prospect. I just haven't been that impressed the times I've seen him play, and what I've read about him made me like him even less.
I thought you were a dolphins fan, My bad. Probably because you said i wish that draft would happen, as a jets fan it would be a pretty good one imo, So i figured you were douching.
I might be the biggest Dolphin hater on this site. And I'm not kidding. And even though theres no OL depth that would such a ridiculous defensive haul that's it's damn near impossible that it happens. Wayyy too optimistic on your projections IMO. I'm not sure Carter lasts til end of round 3 due to this being a weak safety class and I think theres no chance Fua is there til the 5th.
I Didn't read his whole sig, I just saw his location and assumed. Again, I apologize. Can you ever forgive me for these misfortunes ?
