I could see that if they had to throw deep, but Toomer and Smith are both outstanding possession receivers who find space underneath. The Giants needed 3 yards, and with those two, and Boss and Ward, they had plenty of weapons to get it through the air. It was a shitty call, and it basically ended the season.
Stupid, stupid, stupid play calling. Run outside! Stopped. Run outside! Stopped. Run inside! Ten yard gain. ...Run outside!
Wow. Eagles do the Giants a minor favor. Stopping the clock with two minutes left on the incompletion.
Teams really hurt themselves by not going for it on 4th down enough. Coaches simply don't have the guts.
Because Andy Reid is one of the worst coaches in the league. If I was Jim Johnson I would've caned that tubby moron to death years ago.