Are you honestly saying you'd take Brady, Brees, Roethlisberger, and Manning (guys who have 2-6 years left max) over Luck (a guy who probably has 14+ left barring serious injury)? I'm sorry but that's idiotic. Rodgers is the only one you can legitimately make an argument for over Luck, and even he's a stretch.
Some of you even take threads that are specifically NOT about the QB and turn them into the same old QB discussions. Unbelievable. Do some of you know any other players except for QBs???
Judges I think we have a winner, in the non QB category, and the team make up as it stands today Clavin Johnson is our Man If Geno does develop or we draft or acquire a true elite franchise QB with what we have on D and O right now we would be a force to recon with for many years to come.
funny how hobbes still didnt clarify his statement. hobbes i am asking you again are you saying you would take mark sanchez over andrew luck?
Calvin Johnson, paired with growing Stephen Hill, would provide excellent deep threat outside. Double-post, sort of. Add a good TE or two, and you've got an offense you can't fail. Ah... Sanchez If Jets can get Calvin, they should go with accurate QB, not Sanchez. Running game will take off by the sheer presence of megatron.
Since I can't take a quarterback, I'm gonna take the player who most effects the opposing team's quarterback. JJ Watt. His swats, pressures, and sacks effect the opposing quarterback big time and is game changing.
I agree with ANDREW LUCK. If you want to win consistently you need a great QB and he is that or will be in the very near future.
Winner!!!! For those not saying a QB, wake-up! THis kid is a true pocket QB, BIG, STRONG and will be in the league long after those scat QBs are broken and gone.
