IMO, those that point to the winning % with CP are the same people that point to edwards making the playoffs in 3 of 5 years here. jil
The latter is a happenstance of the former. IMHO, the Chad detractors, exhibit the same level of football intelligence, as the 'sports journalists' that picked the 2006 Jets to be a reflection of the 2005 Jets. It should have been no surprise to anyone that a team that won 4 games with a 3rd and fourth string QB, was good enough to win 10, with a top tier QB. To me, thats not a great leap of faith, or logic.