I think this might be some of my better work. yeah, I know we all hate the Bills, but I think McGahee is a great player. Let me know what you think.
Not your best...fonts are just too plain for me, especially with this grunge like sig. Also, don't like the combination of the regular uniforms and their old uniforms.
It has improved a bit. Still not digging the font. Maybe just use a thick font and make it into a grunge font by brushing over the font layer or something. Also, another thing I noticed is the glow is a tad bit much. Maybe lower the visibility of the glow a little or something? I'd rather you get some opinions from other graphics makers though too, because I haven't been at my A-Game lately.
The glow does seem a bit excessive in this sig. I also think the top pic would be better off if it was Willis in the regular uniform. The bright blue doesn't really work with the grunge sig and background you have going in this one.
as they both said, the glow on the main render is a bit much. That blue just doesnt work well with the dark blue you have in the background... maybe find a picture of him in their traditional jerseys that may work better.