Bingo! If Sheff can return, he is a DH. Bernie stays for another two or three years as a utility outfielder. Giambi and Phillips split time at first. When Phillips plays first, Giambi DHs, and Sheff is the odd man out who sits.
i agree with most of you guys but how could you not want soriano back....imo a top 6-7 overall player he has everything
He's consistently inconsistent. And he is has a very itchy trigger finger. He has loads of talent, but he's too much of a loose cannon.
I'd prefer none of the above, as it would take some high end prospects to get one of them. However if I had to choose one...My heart would say Abreu(one of my fav. players) and my head says Soriano(would add speed and athleticism to line-up).
Imagine if we got Soriano in FA this year... In essense, we got ARod for free, just as if Soriano took a 3 year vacation from the Yankees Now, i'm not saying i want that... I'm all for work the farm system
None of them. Abreu is the only one worth getting, but I wouldn't even want him. Soriano doesn't have "everything", infact he lacks the most important thing, a high OBP, one that isn't in direct correlation with a high or low batting average.
His K : BB is still 2 : 1. It was a blessing when he was traded (even greater when you realize we traded him for a top 3 player in the world), let's not bring that headache back.
You guys have to remember - what are you willing to give up for Soriano? I personally wouldn't want any of them if I was a Yank fan. Guillen is a crybaby, Abreu is afraid of the wall, Stewart would fill a lead-off role which the Yankees don't need, and Soriano is terrible defensively and will probably cost atleast Melky Cabrera. Keep what you have for now, and as everyone is saying use Matsui - Damon - Cabrera for the next few years.
