It really depends on things. 1. Do you play Geno or Simms just because the season is over? Better to evaluate them than a veteran like Vick who you know what he is. But in the end whats really left to evaluate? Especially with Geno at this point? Also, realistically, I think we all know what Simms is anyway. 2. Do you let Vick play in hopes of seeing if he could be your short term answer? Realistically, if your going to draft a QB for next year you need a veteran on the roster, particularly one who can play and win games. You could take this time to see just exactly what Vick has left. The biggest problem with that though is that Vick is hurt all the time and I don't even know if he can start and finish the final 8 games of this lost, disastrous season. I understand the idea of letting Geno play to get the best draft pick possible but Rex Ryan isn't going to do that. He wants to win games. That's something a first year HC and GM might do with a depleted roster and holdover QB who stinks. I guess if I had to pick i'd say go with Vick till the bye week and then throw in either Simms or Geno. But I really don't know where to go from here at this position.
