Statjeff makes a valid point, that are we arguing football smarts vs. intelligence as a whole. We have the Most Knowledgeable poster, which is referring to football. However we have a Least Intelligent Poster, which refers to the overall brain activity going on in a particular poster's cranium. A simply tweak of the name, may be in effect.
I agree with the change. It makes sense. If we want to judge the award based on overall intelligence, we'd have a huge list to work from.
Agreed. Unless you want Most/Least intelligent posters as well. One guy who can, against all odds, argue successfully for Vicks and OJ's innocents is brilliant. On the other hand one who can be argueing for Jerry Rice being the best WR of all time and still sound like an idiot..... well.....
That was my other recommendation as well, although I'm not sure that I would agree with your definition of brilliance!
Yes, just for the sake of consistency. I would still want a Least Intelligent Poster, we just don't need to glorify a king of logic to counteract it.
