Rather than squeeze out another mock, I thought this would be more telling of where I have guys rated. Let me know what you think, I'd be happy to explain any reasoning. BTW- Yes, I really do think McCoy is the best player in the draft. His natural ability to change a game gets him the SLIGHTEST advantage over Suh. It is really paper thin. 1. DT Gerald McCoy, Oklahoma* 2. DT Ndamukong Suh, Nebraska 3. S Eric Berry, Tennessee* 4. CB Joe Haden, Florida* 5. QB Jimmy Clausen, Notre Dame* 6. QB Sam Bradford, Oklahoma* 7. LB Rolando McClain, Alabama* 8. WR Dez Bryant, OK State* 9. OT Russ Okung, OK State 10. RB C.J. Spiller, Clemson 11. OT Bryan Bulaga, Iowa* 12. CB Kyle Wilson, Boise State 13. DE Derrick Morgan, Georgia Tech* 14. DT Brian Price, UCLA* 15. S Earl Thomas, Texas** 16. LB Sergio Kindle, Texas 17. DE Brandon Graham, Michigan 18. DT Dan Williams, Tennessee 19. WR Demaryius Thomas, Georgia Tech* 20. RB Ryan Mathews, Fresno State* 21. OT Anthony Davis, Rutgers* 22. DT Jared Odrick, Penn State 23. CB Devin McCourty, Rutgers 24. DE Jason Pierre-Paul, USF* 25. OG Mike Iupati, Idaho 26. LB Sean Weatherspoon, Missouri 27. OT Trent Williams, Oklahoma 28. DE Carlos Dunlap, Florida* 29. C Maurkice Pouncey, Florida* 30. RB Jahvid Best, Cal* 31. OT Bruce Campbell, Maryland* 32. S Taylor Mays, USC 33. TE Jermaine Gresham, Oklahoma* 34. DE Everson Griffen, USC* 35. LB Ricky Sapp, Clemson 36. WR Damian Williams, USC* 37. OT Charles Brown, USC 38. DT Terrence Cody, Alabama 39. S Nate Allen, USF 40. WR Golden Tate, Notre Dame* 41. DE Jerry Hughes, TCU 42. DT Cam Thomas, North Carolina 43. LB Donald Butler, Washington 44. RB Montario Hardesty, Tennessee 45. CB Kareem Jackson, Alabama* 46. DT Linval Joseph, East Carolina* 47. OT Rodger Saffold, Indiana 48. TE Rob Gronkowski, Arizona 49. CB Brandon Ghee, Wake Forest 50. WR Arrelious Benn, Illinois* 51. S Morgan Burnett, Georgia Tech* 52. S Chris Cook, Virginia 53. TE Aaron Hernandez, Florida* 54. OG John Jerry, Ole Miss 55. WR Andre Roberts, Citadel 56. LB Daryl Washington, TCU 57. DT Geno Atkins, Georgia 58. WR Carlton Mitchell, USF* 59. OG Vladimir Ducasse, UMass 60. WR Brandon LaFell, LSU 61. RB Ben Tate, Auburn 62. OT Selvish Capers, West Virginia 63. DT Lamarr Houston, Texas 64. CB Jerome Murphy, USF 65. RB Jonathan Dwyer, Georgia Tech* 66. S Darrell Stuckey, Kansas 67. DT Tyson Alualu, Cal 68. QB Dan LeFevour, Central Michigan 69. RB Toby Gerhart, Stanford* 70. OG Mike Johnson, Alabama 71. LB Eric Norwood, South Carolina 72. S T.J. Ward, Oregon 73. LB Navorro Bowman, Penn State* 74. LB Brandon Spikes, Florida 75. WR Mardy Gilyard, Cincinnati 76. OT Jason Fox, Miami 77. DE Thadeus Gibson, Ohio State* 78. CB Perrish Cox, OK State 79. DT Torrell Troup, UCF 80. DE Jason Worilds, Virginia Tech* 81. CB Javier Arenas, Alabama 82. QB Colt McCoy, Texas 83. DE Alex Carrington, Arkansas State 84. WR Taylor Price, Ohio 85. QB Tim Tebow, Florida 86. CB Akwasi Owusu-Ansah, Indiana (PA) 87. RB Anthony Dixon, Mississippi State 88. LB Koa Misi, Utah 89. LB Pat Angerer, Iowa 90. DE Jermaine Cunningham, Florida 91. WR Dezmon Briscoe, Kansas* 92. CB Ameri Spievey, Iowa* 93. OT Jared Veldheer, Hillside 94. OG Jon Asamoah, Illinois 95. TE Jimmy Graham, Miami 96. DT Arthur Jones, Syracuse 97. S Chad Jones, LSU* 98. LB Sean Lee, Penn State 99. DT Jeff Owens, Georgia 100. OT Kyle Calloway, Iowa
3 things. McCoy over Suh. Reasoning? Clausen over Bradford. Reasoning? Kindle over Graham. Reasoning?
Excellent Job!! My Top 50 is close with a few differences. I have Jason Pierre-Paul, Arrelious Benn, Kareem Jackson and Brandon Spikes much higher. Ricky Sapp and Mt Cody didn't even crack my top 50.
You know I love Sapp, and I think Cody has a lot of value in other styles of 3-4, just not the Jets. For instance, he would be a nice replacement for Jamal Williams, or might be an option with Minnesota as a Pat Williams replacement next to Kevin Williams. With the other players it just came down to personal preference. For instance Spikes, I would honestly take Donald Butler and Daryl Washington ahead of him, without question, plus I think he might be exclusively a 34 player. For Benn and Jackson, I moved them up a bit before I posted it and I think they'll both be taken higher, it's just that overlap between Rds 1 and 2 is so deep. McCoy has an explosiveness in his game that I think will translate to making him a star in the NFL. The fact that these players will be going to bad teams that need impact guys, you have to factor in who will be able to make the big plays. Suh is phenomenal, but I think McCoy will be able to make more big plays that won't even give the other ten guys a chance to mess up. McCoy is a mistake eraser, because on any play he could be in front of the QB/RB in 5 steps or less. Bradford's arm health is a big factor to me still, because I know what Clausen can do. Both are leaders, both (when healthy) have good NFL arms, but I think when it comes to being polished as a QB Clausen has a little advantage. Now I'm not saying that Bradford can't be coached to make up that difference, but if I'm taking a franchise, I want as little questions as possible. Injury and offense are enough to make Sam second. Kindle gets the nod because i think he represents the 100% prototype to play 34 OLB in the NFL. The fact that he has linebacker experience, proved himself as a dynamic rusher, and is coming off the success of Brian Orakpo means a lot. Brandon Graham is a great prospect too, but I just think that Kindle's proven ability as a drop back guy makes him more valuable. That said, in a 43 Graham takes the lead, because I don't think Kindle's game would be as dynamic with his hand on the ground every play. Ward is nasty. And Hughes' ranking reflects his potential position in the CFL Draft, I just felt bad leaving him out.