So I missed my draft but ended up autodrafting a pretty decent team, however Im really weak at certain spots most notably 3rd base, where I have Alex Gordon starting. Another team offered me Arod, Tulowitzki, and my choice of Tim Hudson or Javier Vasquez and Jim Thome or Todd Helton for Johan, Rollins, and Victor Martinez. My pitching is pretty deep, I also have Brian McCann at catcher, and this is the best deal I could talk the other guy into. Do I pull the trigger?
Let's see. . . ARod > Rollins Tulowitzki = Martinez Hudson/Vasquez << Johan It's a pretty even trade. I say don't make it just cuz you are worried about being weak at certain positions. You don't need to be strong at every position. Take the guys you personally like more and don't worry too much about where you are weak.
If I were you I'd counter with McCann, Johan, Rollis for Arod, Tulowitzki, Hudson. You're downgrading at SS and SP, but you pick up one of the top offensive talents in the game at 3b and you're keeping the better of your two catchers. Thome and Helton are over... why bother picking up dead weight? Just my 2 cents.
