exactly.... people need an excuse as to why we are bad, so they are grasping on to "well we just need vick to play and we'd be 4-1" type nonsense. when its clear to any unbiased observer this team is bad top to bottom, not just at QB. is vick better? probably? is he so much better he can lead a team of scrubs to wins? hell no. play geno all year, so when the year is over you can say you evaluated him enough and move the fuck on. the worst thing that could happen is you keep shuffling the two, then next year you say" geno needs more time" and stick with him even longer
Vick delivered a 20 yard`laser for 7 points. Should have been a 20.5 yard laser and it would have counted.
The jury is not out on Geno Smith, he will never be a starting caliber qb in the NFL. His awareness, foot work and accuracy are absolutely dreadful.
uhhhhhhh vick couldn't score against san diegos 2nd team....he drove down the field on a pass interference call and stil couldn't score...vick isn't the answer....geno isnt the answer...they both are terrible. what will happen is rex will be able to play out the season, geno will continue to be a below average qb, our defense will get scorched by any qb facing them, we will go 6-10, then rex will get fired, idzik will hire his guy from seattle(that defensive coord), and we will have a top 10 pick so hopefully we either use it for qb wr or a play maker.
That is so true. Vick wasn't the starter and didn't practice as a starter. He just comes into the middle of a 21-0 game. No one is going to do well in that situation. It's like people here don't watch football. Vick should have been the starter from day one. Geno sucked last year, he is extremely in experienced, that's expected. But we're not a rebuilding team. We don't have time to gamble on Geno and hope he improves.
Why argue over the fat chick or the ugly one. Under Rex, the Jets are where QB's go to die. Does anyone argue that under a good coach, both Sanchez and Smith would have been better than they are today? I am not saying they would have been great or even good but not as bad as they turned out.
Yes, I argue this. Both Sanchez and Geno suck and would have sucked under any coach including Bill Walsh and Joe Gibbs.
I could only imagine if Gina started at our own 5 yrd line twice. Two more pick sixes added and the score would have been even more embarrassing. To start him again is a friggin joke, don't let the door hit you in the ass Rex.
If Rex had half a nut sack he'd give Vick a week of snaps with the ones in practice and a start so he's not coming in cold to a 21-0 situation where the d is teeing off on the pass. But he doesn't and he'll be fired soon anyway. I don't think it matters much who QB's this week anyway. Peyton is dropping 40+ on this defense.
Smith has been supported by the CS from opening day of camp, and in his second season has a half of football as bad as any i have ever seen in the NFL. Enough already. At least Vick did not turn the ball over, and his problems seemed more to do with lack of practice with the receivers. Smith Fans can't say that about their boy. At this point i have to wonder about Smith Fans, more than ever.
