Well both of your first statements are definitely up for debate. He very well may be the best athlete in the draft and he very well may be the best football player in the draft. I think one one can debate it either way, it is not cut and dry.
With the Titans? Not a damn thing. He had a couple of 4-game streaks then he disappointed again. Vince Young is not a starter in this league.
Ironic that they are all relevant again. VY starting in Philly Leinart starting in Houston and Reggie looking kinda like a decent RB in Miami.
That is an absolutely perfect comparison. Both guys were always touted as "natural winners," both guys were expected to revolutionize the position, and both guys will ultimately fail as starting QBs. I'm not quite ready to close the book on Young, however. I'd like to see him next year, after a full season under Andy Reid (who, no matter what you think of him as a head coach, has been proven to be one of the great QB coaches in football.)
Vince has more INTs than TD...he gets all this talk because he has a habit of winning games in the 4th qtr or OT. Don't confuse dramatic wins for a good QB. His throwing motion is like when a normal person tries to throw with their off hand...ugly.