Once (and depending on who you talk to, still) graded as a Top 5-6 pick in this draft, it would seem there have been growing concerns about Michigan defensive tackle Alan Branch. Consider the following... Scout.com's combine report about Branch said the following: Branch worked hard and ran reasonably well in the forty. And while he flashed athleticism he quickly faded during the practice session and seemed out of shape. His stock is slipping. Several teams we spoke with at today's workouts said were it any ordinary player from any ordinary program they'd probably stamp him with a third round grade. Expect Branch to make a Jimmy Kennedy like fall in the draft. Recently, Mel Kiper dropped Branch down his big board. Once near the top, Branch currently appears at 24 and is Kiper's third ranked defensive tackle available in this class behind Louisville's Amobi Okoye and Tennessee's Justin Harrell. Now that Michigan has had their pro day, more concerning reports are starting to come in. From NFL.com's Gil Brandt: Branch ran the short shuttle in 4.81 seconds and the three-cone drill in 7.50. Kansas City defensive line coach Tim Krumrie worked Branch hard during the position drills, and the scouts there said Branch did not look like he was in very good shape. Scout.com offers a similar assessment: Alan Branch did not fare as well. Just as we reported at the combine, Branch looked sluggish and out of shape during the position drills. Furthermore, NFL Draft Scout's Rob Rang also indicated that Branch's stock may be slipping. The site's profile on Branch lists the following recent news: Michigan's Pro Day isn't until March 16, and with a solid workout at the Combine, Branch won't necessarily have anything to gain. The concern scouts have is the more they put in the film, the more concerned they are that Branch was simply able to over-power collegiate players. Even his most ardent supporters would agree that Branch isn't your typical playmaking defensive tackle, and his pass rush skills will never earn comparisons to Warren Sapp. Still, for a player who is thought to be a physically dominant presence, Branch was so meek in Combine interviews with teams that some are a little worried he'll struggle to adapt to the intensity of the pro game. Don't expect Branch to drop far. Houston, Miami, Atlanta and San Francisco, teams selecting between No. 8 and No. 11 overall, all could use help inside. However, Branch's status as a top five pick is in question. So should teams be wary of the large Michigan lineman? Is Branch really slipping down on draft boards because of concerns about his work ethic and motivation? Or are the labels of being sluggish and out of shape not exceptionally out of the ordinary for a man of his massive size?
Other than his size and the planet theory, I never understood his consensus TOP 10 Ranking .. I watched him plenty and I didn't see a dominant player He's not bad, he doesn't suck, but he's nothing special either .. that is, other than his size .. and he was really disappointing in the Ohio State Game to my eyes .. I actually keyed on him and I have to agree with that one scout who said he looks like a 3rd RD Pick .. maybe not overall, but he certainly looked like a 3rd RD Pick in that game .. he was completely neutralized But I still expect him to be a TOP 15/20 Pick based solely on the planet theory and reputation I can't see him falling any further than that, but I wouldn't be shocked PS. I have Okoye ahead of Branch too Oh yeah, and it wouldn't bother me if he fell to Miami and they took him .. I wouldn't lose a wink of sleep over that pick
I like him as a prospect, but I did think he was less athletic than given credit for. I actually always thought Branch's out of shapeness was obviously. He isn't exactly a lean guy, and he never had great stamina in college. It's a problem with alot of Michigan's big men lately (Gabe Watson). Still, if he fell to us I'd like to see what our coaching staff can do to set him straight. He's got serious potential.
Yeh I fully agree, Okoye is a better prospect, 30 pounds extra fat is not 30 pounds extra muscle,Him being compared to John Henderson is a joke, while they may weight the same, Henderson is a lean 330 pounder. I do not want Branch, questionable work ethic by a big man means bust, just the same as questionable field tenasity, See: The morman school Samoans