Does he have a job right now? Has he been criticized for losing touch of what it takes to run an NFL offense? Seems like he certainly fizzled out in GB, no? Or, do you see that different too?
McCarthy is a has been he’s looked completely disinterested in coaching for like 3 seasons now the fat fuck should just do analysis for the nfl network no thank you
Not sure how long you have been following the Jets but Bill Belichick was actually the coach of the Jets for a (very) brief period. What could have been!
This is indeed becoming a one big joke. There are exactly 4 QBs in the history of NFL that won more than 2 SBs in their entire career. Many great QB have not won anything. Rogers winning one is not an underachievement that can count against Mike. We have a unique opportunity to bring a winner and a SB champ, who coached great QBs to be the head coach, who is not over the hill at 55. Instead we are choosing NCAA guy with losing record. Much like we got Bowles instead of waiting for Quinn. Same old Jets.
You guys are better than that, it’s not as black and white as everyone makes it out to be. The 2007 Giants defense that knocked out the Packers in the championship game, was the same Giants defense that beat the New England patriots in the SB. We can’t hold it against Bellicheat or Mcarthy that Coughlin was just as good a HC and was able to strategize better against them. Mcarthy is a solid HC, for us to nitpick and criticize him the way this board has is silly. I know this board is better than this, much better!
What is your definition of failure? McCarthy is not longer employed with GB. Rodgers is. McCarthy found success with the team but ultimately failed to appease the city, owners, and fans enough to keep him. That is failing and very damaging to many that see what he had and lost. I'm just not all in on the idea. I would support it but I have a lot of concerns about the potential hire as a fan. That doesnt make me lazy. Which is my only point really.
The idea that Mike McCarthy is gonna come here and be like parcells is laughable Who does the sports pope say we should hire
If you truly think Mike McCarthy's run in green bay can be considered a failure, then I'm not even going to waste my time trying to convince you otherwise.
No. Man. You bring up Coughlin. He would have the exact same level of criticism as MM, hell, probably more. I've just never fell for something that just doesnt entirely make sense for me. Everyone seemed to want Jon Gruden not to long ago and that situation is looking real rough right now. How many would want him now after the year he just had in Oakland? I'm just saying, having these red flags should alarm people. Its okay to question why a coach would get fired when they had the best QB in the league in a pass hungry NFL.. No? I'm not bashing him but I'm also pointing out the red flags I see...while maintaining it's not lazy to go against or resist a coach with these red flags. All I'm saying.
i use to really think so. But some of the vitriol and superficial arguments by some make me wonder if we have significantly digressed. I don't know what the real answer is, but MM IMO is a huge upgrade and possibly the best option for a team in total disarray, without rudder, nor leadership. Personally, I find the statement " He only won one Super Bowl with Aaron, thus he is a reject" completely comical, almost as mind boggling comical as the comment " we should have kept TB"
Okay.. don't. He found success. Yep, once. He also found the door too. He failed to keep up with today's NFL with the best QB in the land. So, yeah, If I was hiring on just that one year, where he made It all the way, with an offense that worked much differently back then, sure... Things change. Things evolve. MM has not. If he can show the Jets he has ebolved during those interviews. Okay, I'm hopeful. I doubt he did though.. People want to act like the Jets are dumb for not handing him a contract as soon as they fired Bowles. I just dont get it.
The way he was fired is a huge red flag. Two years in a row no playoffs. Lost his QB's attention. The team president hates him. He doesn't want to be here. He's got a good resume but he may well be done. If the reason to hire him is he was successful with a good organization we should also look at what that organization did.
I’m not saying that we can’t look at red flags, however all HC come to the end of their career at some point. Is Mcarthy there at this point? I don’t think so. Andy Reid is still productive after he left the Eagles. Bellicheat uses the same system he formulated years ago, uses power running game and short passes with the occasional downfield throws. He doesn’t use RPO, or whatever the newest fad is, he sticks to sound football strategies that are tried and true. There are only a hand full of HC that produce at this level on a consistent basis and Mcarthy has been one of them. The name of the game is the FQB, Jets have one, they don’t need a guy who needs on OTJT and is going to get out coached by bellicheat twice a year in a very tough division. For me Mcarthy is the ideal candidate to accomplish everything Jets need, experience, QB development, put together a good CS, and hopefully get Mac to get some offensive weapons in the draft.
The man who has the best pulse and offensive mind moving forward with today's NFL. If its, McCarthy. If he is the hire. I'm All In. If he doesnt grasp the evolution of today's NFL, then I want the candidate that gets it. Whoever he may be. IDC. I'm just not subscribing to this bandwagon for McCarthy for the sake of his past successes. Just because his success in Greenbay looks far better than our teams success level for the last forever years, doesnt mean he will provide us that just because he found success with another team.. I keep looking at it. All I see is... there is a reason you were fired. His main knock that I've heard from GB fans and media. He has lost touch with today's NFL. His offenses are stale and opposite of innovating.. That's the last thing we need here. IMO So, it he is the hire. I'm ALL IN. I just have my concern with what is obvious to me. That's all.
If its rhule then how have we gotten better? Or at least serious? It would be the same old jets. Cheap bastard johnsons always dumpster diving for an eclair and 4 years later the fire alarm goes off and they are pushing elderly women out of the way. Not sure I pulled off my costanza analogy, but hey, I almost gave it an effort. Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk
