we would be if he costs us a roster spot for a better player the difference between him and petty is negligible at this point and that who would replace smith not Hack
Dude geno was here no matter what. Keep thinking it was pettys injury. I do like pettys progress. Next year is his year. He can be the starter next season. Sent from my SM-N930V using Tapatalk
I saw that, did you read my post or are you just being argumentative....if they don't stash Petty on the IR then yes Geno should go he has no future here and he is gone after this year so tell me all things being equal between Petty and Smith who would you keep. They are both the same age but one has had bad career and the other has had no career yet but has grown more in one yr then the other.
Yknow...I don't know if this Chandler Worthy guy had a chance of making the roster anyway...but you think he's feeling a bit glum with Hack bouncing and airmailing everything thrown his way? Jesus Christ Hack the receivers are DOWN HERE! Theyre not 8 feet tall!
I read it and you are still wrong. So what if Petty isn't IR'd but may not be healthy to start the season. Are you good if Fitz goes down against Cincy and Hack is the backup? Thats what you are saying.
Ummm im.pretty sure petty will be here next season and im pretty sure hes got a good chance to start. Dunno where this magic qb is coming from. Sent from my SM-N930V using Tapatalk
If Fitz goes down the season is over at that point going forward any way. This staff loves Smith so much they played a on thumbed injured qb last yr then roll Geno out there. It all depends on what they do with Petty and his injury
I miss-read I thought you meant Geno would be here next yr and start here. I think this staff can't wait to distance themselves from anything Idzick touched with the exception of Richardson
You didn't answer the question. But I'm not going to keep going with this. Bottom line is based on what we've seen tonight between Petty's injury and Hack playing like the inexperienced rookie he is, anyone who advocates for trading Geno now is just clueless or just hates him beyond reason.
We don't know about Petty's injury why do keep ignoring that fact that I said it depended on Petty's injury WTF dude seriously. I answered your question. If think this team should keep Geno and Petty is healthy and Geno costs a peake or andersona roster spot then I need to question your reading comprehension look at my posts previous "It all depends on what they do with Petty and his injury" My answer to Zace "WE SHOULD CUT GENO...I don't think I stuttered, a 1st yr player makes that mistake and grows Geno makes that mistake every game. the only way geno should make this team is if Petty is stashed on the IR. Every knew that hack needed time and people are getting pissed over this pick get pissed next yr if it happens get pissed in the regular season if Geno gets a chance to do it"
lol so I'm guessing the Eagles broadcasters sent them the worst angles possible? That couldnt have been clearer.