Come on man. Don't you know that you can only rate the guy based on his past failures? You can't count his positives. Come on man!
This thread is probably in need of a change of direction, anyway, so I noticed some article making the point that the Raiders are interested in Vick. So, if you were Vick, where would you rather go? Overall the Jets have more talent, and are a better chance to make the playoffs. The Jets also have the better CS. And the Oakland fanbase has far more face painters. So there are those reasons in the Jets' favor. Despite all that, would Vick be more likely to start in Oakland? Here it may not come down to the talent of the Qb's already on the respective rosters, as it is the willingness of the CS to let a vet FA Qb come in and really get a shot at starting. Imo Vick could look at it this way, and decide where to go on this last factor alone.