1. Herm Edwards Record: 39-41 (5) seasons Playoff Seasons: 3 Division Titles: 1 Playoff Wins: 2 2. Rex Ryan Record: 46-50 (6) seasons Playoff Seasons: 2 Division Titles: 0 Playoff Wins: 4 3. Eric Mangini Record: 23-25 (3) seasons Playoff Seasons: 1 Division Titles: 0 Playoff Wins: 0 4. Todd Bowles Record: 20-28 (3) seasons Playoff Seasons: 0 Division Titles: 0 Playoff Wins: 0 Obviously the big debate will be Herm vs Rex. I think Herm was a slightly better coach despite the success Rex had in his first two years. Herm actually made the playoffs every year Pennington was healthy. I thought Bowles (2015) and Mangini (2008) had the two most talented rosters of all these guys. Not surprised the guys that actually had a pulse did reasonably well and the two comatose guys Woody hired were disasters.