[I Am The Stig]

Originally Posted by Diddy

According to Skip Bayless, he is a force of competitive nature, and is clutch unlike Sanchez. Seriously, does anybody even remotely remember 2010? His obsession to Tebow is sickening, though it does give him ratings.

I think he trolls on purpose to the point that he doesn't even believe what he says. It's all for the ratings, he's developed a personality of being a sports troll.

[JetBlue]

Originally Posted by AarontheJet

How the hell would Tebow make this team better?

Sanchez has been so bad that it is simply more realistic that Tebow would have performed better than Sanchez. For fuck's sake, Sanchez is 32 out of 34 in the league. There was nowhere to go but up with any QB that replaced Sanchez, Tebow or otherwise.

beyond that, even last year, the much maligned Tebow had a higher QB rating than Sanchez has this year. it may be only 2% higher, but Sanchez has been so shitty that a 2% improvement at the QB position would have been a significant improvement.

[TurkJetFan]

Originally Posted by dr.velociraptor

Sanchez has been playing poorly and after 70 yards with 3 INTs and a sub 50% completion % he needed to sit down so I'm not playing Monday morning QB.

But in reality based on McElroy's scouting report I don't believe he will be a franchise leading QB, he'll make a nice living as a backup but probably isn't the man for us.

So if we're really moving away from Sanchez there's really nothing to celebrate, we're once again rutterless without a franchise QB and that's depressing. Sanchez being benched is anti-climactic, we cheered for it but now that it's here it's like "OK now what"? Management has lost all faith in him, he's done. And we're left with McElroy and Tebone...

who brought this guy?

[RuJFan]

Originally Posted by Big Blocker

I don't think there's anything mysterious about why Sanchez was benched yesterday. Suspicious about the connection that Tebow was not dressed when it happened? Really?

The Jets do not want Tebow as their starting Qb. That's why it went down like it did. No mystery whatsoever.

accidentally, it seems I'm not the only one. Was listening to Namath on my way home. The topic, of course was Jets QB situation. Namath also mentioned that he thinks that QB decisions are influenced from above. He specifically qualified that he has no inside knowledge. His exact word was that he has "a feeling". Still interesting and if his feeling is right than my speculation is not too far-fetched.

[endydee]

Originally Posted by RevisIsland18

and eli manning has had more turn overs than sanchez since 2009...just goes to show you that turnover stat sometime could be overrated

If that is how you feel, fine. How many of Eli's turnovers were red zone interceptions? How many games did Eli's turnovers cost the Giants points and wins? Oh yeah, how many Super Bowls has Eli won? I am a Jets fan, and damn glad Sanchez has been handed the clipboard. Can't wait until he's handed the pink slip, and shown the door.

[Big Blocker]

Originally Posted by RuJFan

accidentally, it seems I'm not the only one. Was listening to Namath on my way home. The topic, of course was Jets QB situation. Namath also mentioned that he thinks that QB decisions are influenced from above. He specifically qualified that he has no inside knowledge. His exact word was that he has "a feeling". Still interesting and if his feeling is right than my speculation is not too far-fetched.

In the short run the focus here is on the next game, and this week specifically on who will start at Qb. There is still the very slim mathematical possibility the Jets can make the playoffs (although I don't really think about that more than I just did), and also to see how the roster does in playing out the season. But at some point I think the forum will take a look in hindsight at the Tebow trade and what it was all about.

On one hand I don't trust everything Ryan says by a long shot. That includes being skeptical all along about this so called plan to integrate Tebow into a Sanchez led offense. But maybe in fact there was a plan, and that was that Tebow was never going to be the starter, and they would try and work Tebow in when and where it made sense to do so.

Of course as a plan that was not much of one, but it has gone down the way it has to at least some extent because when he has gotten the ball, Tebow has done next to nothing with it. Maybe the plan was really an experiment, and the experiment failed.

All that aside, and looking at it objectively, it was always going to be an issue in bringing in an O that would be tailored to Sanchez, and then considering changing up that O mid season to bring in Tebow, as would be necessary to make that change. Even the Tebots here, if they care to address the point, would not say that Tebow can and should run the same O as the Jets have now. That's not what Denver did last year.

Add in that McElroy is much better suited to run the current Jet O than Tebow is, and that he's accurate and shows promise.

To what extent was Tebow being injured a factor? I think it provided a certain amount of cover, but that doesn't address what Ryan would have done if Tebow were not injured. I don't really know, but my guess is Ryan would not have put Tebow in even if he were fully healthy.

[DemoIsland]

Originally Posted by Big Blocker

In the short run the focus here is on the next game, and this week specifically on who will start at Qb. There is still the very slim mathematical possibility the Jets can make the playoffs (although I don't really think about that more than I just did), and also to see how the roster does in playing out the season. But at some point I think the forum will take a look in hindsight at the Tebow trade and what it was all about.

On one hand I don't trust everything Ryan says by a long shot. That includes being skeptical all along about this so called plan to integrate Tebow into a Sanchez led offense. But maybe in fact there was a plan, and that was that Tebow was never going to be the starter, and they would try and work Tebow in when and where it made sense to do so.

Of course as a plan that was not much of one, but it has gone down the way it has to at least some extent because when he has gotten the ball, Tebow has done next to nothing with it. Maybe the plan was really an experiment, and the experiment failed.

All that aside, and looking at it objectively, it was always going to be an issue in bringing in an O that would be tailored to Sanchez, and then considering changing up that O mid season to bring in Tebow, as would be necessary to make that change. Even the Tebots here, if they care to address the point, would not say that Tebow can and should run the same O as the Jets have now. That's not what Denver did last year.

Add in that McElroy is much better suited to run the current Jet O than Tebow is, and that he's accurate and shows promise.

To what extent was Tebow being injured a factor? I think it provided a certain amount of cover, but that doesn't address what Ryan would have done if Tebow were not injured. I don't really know, but my guess is Ryan would not have put Tebow in even if he were fully healthy.

Agreed. If Tebow was going to play, it would have happened already. We have seen who wanted Tebow here and who didn't.

[mr nyjet]

Originally Posted by NYJetsRevis24

MclRoy has Russel Wilson like qualitys, I want to see what he can do,We already know what Sanchez can do.MclRoy lead that 8 minute drive and ran out the clock, he has great mobility within the pocket to scramble if nessescary, He also is fast and looks like he has a decent arm and he makes smart decisions. I want to see more MclRoy before we say he isn't a "franchise" QB

exactly! they down grade him because he was a 7th round pick. brady was 6th round pick. montana, who some say is amongst best of all time, was 3rd round. unitas was cut by steelers and picked up off sandlot by the colts.

let the guy play and see what you have. you might be surprised. at least you're not shoving $30 million his way since he joined the team to be an interception and fumble machine........

[kubernetes]

Yeah, I really hate the reasoning that "He'll be terrible because that's what his draft report says." Sheesh, if there's one truism in the NFL, you don't know how a player will perform until he actually plays. Give McElroy the job until the end of the season. Let's see if he's got something.