Baker Mayfield by a country mile. His floor is as low as Johnny Football and that means sub zero basement type floor... Josh Rosen is next because he could be Tim Couch and never see the field due to injuries. Darnolds floor is Sanchez turnover robot floor. Allen’s floor is Jamarcus Russell esqu
Worst part is he actually believes he is a fixer of QB's with problems. I asked him where his experience of fixing NFL QB's came from and I didn't get a reply. Even if he has coached elementary, middle school, or high school, which I highly highly doubt, he couldn't have taught them much. It's rare to see any of those levels throwing the football much. Most H.S. Football is run oriented regardless. He watches a lot of NFL network, and repeats what the real QB gurus say and explain, then claims it as his own. I bet the guy has never thrown a football in a game. He won't admit he is wrong even if you prove it. He loves to withdraw his wrong opinions by saying he never said this or that. Gutless, clueless, and gets off on calling people names. A real tough guy on the Internet. Must have been picked on as a child in school. Hahaha
Is basement a floor? I believe Allen is sub-par, substandard. I see him dropping further than anyone in the draft. I would take Jackson and Rudolph before I would pick Allen. Saw an interesting comparison today. How many strong-armed QB have won SB's in the recent era? Flacco, Big Ben? Both Mannings, Foles, Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Montana, Brad Johnson, Dilfer, Warner, Young. Yeah, give me someone who is accurate every day.
Off the Allen train? No way I believe he is the best QB in the draft. I have said before this draft is like no other I can remember because the top 5 QBs are ALL boom or bust prospects. I’d be naive to think anything different.
Lowest floor is quite easily Allen, but he also has the highest ceiling. Will he reach that ceiling or at least get close to it is the big question. Personally, I have my doubts, but I'm not as anti-Allen as most on here may be.
Nope all are boom or bust. Darnold is sloppy and turns the ball over Rosen is fragile and has injuries that keeps him off the field Mayfield is short and comes from a spread offence that has a low success rate at a pro level
No. Darnold/Rosen/Mayfield may very well end up average QB. Or slightly above or below average. But they'll all definitely play in the league for a long time. No QB prospect is perfect and all 3 have tremendous positives as well that they will draw on to survive in the league. Allen is the guy that people have a hard time with. He could be horrifically bad. That won't be the case with the first 3
Anyone who doesn’t say Allen needs to ask themselves what he’s done to prove he can make it in the pros. Being tall doesn’t make you good at football and neither does having a cannon. Just ask Osweiller and Patrick Ramsey. He’s not good at anything a QB is asked to do. That’s alarming.
Allen can't read defenses. Inaccurate and has bad mechanics. That is why I laugh at the Wonderlic test. You could be book smart but common sense dumb. Allen seems the latter.