Giants #25 Pick

[DonnieIsTheKing]

1. Houston Texans- RB Reggie Bush, USC
2. New Orleans Saints- QB Matt Leinart, USC
3. Tennessee Titans- QB Vince Young, Texas
4. New York Jets- OT D'Brickashaw Ferguson, Virginia
5. Green Bay Packers- LB AJ Hawk, Ohio State
6. Oakland Raiders- DE Mario Williams, NC State
7. San Francisco 49ers- RB Deangelo Williams, Memphis
8. We Suck On Dollar Bills- DT Haloti Ngata, Oregon
9. Detroit Lions- QB Jay Cutler, Vandy
10. Arizona Cardinals, RB Lendale White, USC
11. St. Louis Rams- CB Jimmy Williams, Virginia Tech
12. Cleveland Browns- LB Chad Greenway, Iowa
13. Baltimore Ravens- S Michael Huff, Texas
14. Philadelphia Eagles- WR Santonio Holmes, Ohio State
15. Atlanta Falcons- DE Tamba Hali, Penn State
16. Pretty Green Guppies- OT Winston Justice, USC
17. Minnesota Vikings- RB Laurence Maroney, Minnesota
18. Dallas Cowboys- OT Marcus McNeill, Auburn
19. San Diego Chargers- S Darnell Bing, USC
20. Kansas City Chiefs- CB Tye Hill, Clemson
21. Cute Fluffy Pink Pixies- CB Antonio Cromartie, Florida State
22. Denver Broncos (f/WAS)- DE Mathias Kiwanuka, Boston College
23. Tampa Bay Buccaneers- OT Jonathan Scott, Texas
24. Cincinnati Bengals- TE Vernon Davis, Maryland
25. New York Giants- who?

[Pride]

chad jackson wr florida. hes 6'3" ran a 4.28 at the combine and showed good hands. with toomer's future uncertain with the giants at lack of depth at wr the giants go with Chad Jackson

[DonnieIsTheKing]

Bunkley. I really don't know which of the major holes they should fill... but every Giants fan I have talked to either wants a DT or a CB. I figure that since Bunkley is the 2nd best DT and much better value then Youboty, he will be a New York Giant.

DT Brodrick Bunkley, Florida State.

[Pride]

I can see them taking Bunkley but i can not see them taking a corner in the first. they took Webster in the second round last year and he showed much promise

[PinPointPenning10]

Chad Jackson. After the 40 he ran today I see him going even higher than this pick and possibly being the first WR off the board, and the Giants could use one more weapon opposite Burress, they have Toomer who's not bad but he's old and after that they have little talent. Youboty would be a decent pick as well because they are going to lose Will Allen and Peterson's always hurt and I think is also a FA. They drafted Webster last year, but do need another corner, unless they love Curtis DeLoach for some strange reason.

[PinPointPenning10]

chad jackson wr florida. hes 6'3" ran a 4.28 at the combine and showed good hands. with toomer's future uncertain with the giants at lack of depth at wr the giants go with Chad Jackson

Why didn't you vote for him then?

[Learn To Swim]

Youboty. Jackson is great and I'd love to see him in a Giants uni, but unless CB is adressed in the FA period, this is the pick I'd make. Allen is on his way out, Peterson can't stay healthy, and DeLoatch is no more than a fringe player.

[MParty7441]

While Jackson upped his stock a lot, they need a CB

[PRPitbull]

gotta go with Bobo Carpenter. Im not sold on Youboty, i think hes overrated. Carpenter is very good and overshadowed by Hawk. G-Men are thin in linebacking corps. Hopefully, they make a run at Charles Woodson. Youboty wouldnt make much of an impact this year, while Carpenter sure will

[PinPointPenning10]

I probably should of waited to vote because at this point I would've voted for Youboty...they definetly need a CB, MUCH more than they need a LB and I don't see why Carpenter is winning the poll. I think Jackson would be the better pick, but since it doesn't look like he'll win, I would change to help out Youbody if I could, because that's a much better pick than Carpenter IMO.

[kinghenry89]

Carpenter is one of those guys who is so underrated that he's overrated. All anybody can talk about is how he was overshadowed by Hawk and everybody forgets that he was overshadowed by Hawk for a reason--he's not on the same level as him.

Demeco Ryans is, and the Giants will pick him if he's still on the board.

[Mexican Buc]

I can see them taking Bunkley but i can not see them taking a corner in the first. they took Webster in the second round last year and he showed much promise
Exactly. Didn't they draft a CB from LSU. Who was it Webter? They wot draft a CB aain. Between DT or OLB

[PRPitbull]

Carpenter is one of those guys who is so underrated that he's overrated. All anybody can talk about is how he was overshadowed by Hawk and everybody forgets that he was overshadowed by Hawk for a reason--he's not on the same level as him.

well, that tends to happen when you have 2 exceptional linebackers. Granted hes not Hawk, but Hawk is top 5 talent, thats why. Carpenter is still 1st rd talent though. Its not like hes all hype and no talent. Harry Carson was great, but LT was better. Peter Boulware was really good, but Ray Lewis was better. Theres nothing wrong with being slighty less talented than an amazing player. Put Carpenter on another college team, and he would be giving Greenway a run for his money as the 2nd LB drafted this year.

[kinghenry89]

well, that tends to happen when you have 2 exceptional linebackers. Granted hes not Hawk, but Hawk is top 5 talent, thats why. Carpenter is still 1st rd talent though. Its not like hes all hype and no talent. Harry Carson was great, but LT was better. Peter Boulware was really good, but Ray Lewis was better. Theres nothing wrong with being slighty less talented than an amazing player. Put Carpenter on another college team, and he would be giving Greenway a run for his money as the 2nd LB drafted this year.

The only problem is that Carpenter isn't as good as a Carson or Boulware character. Or Demeco Ryans for that matter. People are just tempted to call him underrated because he is in Hawk's shadow when in reality he's pretty fairly judged.

[NYJATW]

well CB is the biggest need imo...but for value...LB is a much better pick for where they stand...


i just went with the leading LB

[Go_Eli]

Wheres the trade down option? I don't really like any of those players for the Giants at 25.

[Pennythetowelboy]

chad jackson is the easy choice. easy.

[DonnieIsTheKing]

Wheres the trade down option? I don't really like any of those players for the Giants at 25.
Oh that would get way too complicated... I'm sure there would have been 10 times where trading down won and that just gets way too messed up for a mock like this.