What if?

[Barry the Baptist]

Suppose the Jets get the #29 pick for Abe and stay at #4

Lets say Cutler is unavailable and we sign Schaffer from Atlanta to play LT

If we draft Mangold with the #29 and Cromartie with the #36 who would you take with the #4?

For me I'm torn between Hawk, Mario Williams and Vernon Davis

[Murrell2878]

I would go with Mario Williams and draft either Croyle in the 3rd or Olson in the 4th

[deviljets7]

Suppose the Jets get the #29 pick for Abe and stay at #4

Lets say Cutler is unavailable and we sign Schaffer from Atlanta to play LT

If we draft Mangold with the #29 and Cromartie with the #36 who would you take with the #4?

For me I'm torn between Hawk, Mario Williams and Vernon Davis

Like the idea of Mangold 29/Cromartie 36. I'll preface this by saying that I'm not 100% sold Cutler, but I'd trade out of the 4 regardless down to the 8-10 range in hopes that Davis is there. With the 2nd rounder take either Jean-Giles or Davin Joseph to fill the hole at guard.

[PinPointPenning10]

Vince Young.


Go ahead, bash me.

[GreenGreek]

In that scenario, I'd trade down and pick up Lendale White or McNeil.

[PinPointPenning10]

If we get the 29th pick, this is what I want.

Sign Shaffer.

4. Cutler. My 2nd choice is Young, but I'd love Mario Williams to replace Abe too.
29. Maroney
36. Manny Lawson...great fit in 3-4
3rd rounder...guard from USC (forgot name)

[AMJets]

I would prefer to trade down, whether we sign Shaffer or not.

[Jonathan_Vilma]

AJ Hawk. Thomas is adequate, and we can't replace Ellis (I'm skeptical, even though I love the guy. He needs to perform at a higher level). Hawk is better than Mario Williams and Hawk will be able to hide Ellis' weaknesses and give us one of the strongest units in the NFL.

#4 - AJ Hawk
#29 - Max Jean-Gilles
#35 - Marcus McNeil

If there's a trade down..

#9 - Winston Justice
#29 - Max Jean-Gilles
#35 - Bobby Carpenter
#40 - Gabe Watson/Brodie Croyle

[1028]

Id trade down and grab Vernon Davis :beer: